Well let’s listen to A minus B and find out.
It’s often the simplest things that can get you excited all over again. Here’s a short anecdote about trusting a whim even when it isn’t immediately clear how it factors into the path that you think you’re on.
A couple months ago I found a small treasure while antiquing with my wife. I’m referring to the 1950s Grommes 24PG HiFi amplifier which I’ve already written about in a previous post. As I type this now, I’m still waiting for my replacement transformers to be custom wound. COVID-19 has understandably slowed down production of many such things, and luckily I’m not in any rush. But the symptoms I observed before diagnosing this amp have had my mental gears turning ever since.
To briefly recap, one of the the Grommes’ two output transformers (it’s a stereo amp) has a break somewhere between its center tap and one end of the primary coil. As a result, this push-pull amplifier was entirely missing one half of the waveform on one of its two channels. After my first listen, I told a close friend and fellow sound engineer, “It’s exactly like I’m listening to A minus B. The center program is missing and I’m only hearing what’s unique to each channel.” Some further troubleshooting revealed that it sounded that way because that was exactly what was happening. Measuring 0v at the plate of one power tube was the clincher. What I had purchased (for the time being) was essentially a bulky differential amplifier.
Without getting too deep, I’ll back up and define a few things. A differential amplifier, in broad terms, is an amp that suppresses all voltage that is common to its two inputs and then amplifies only the difference that remains. In the case of a stereo audio signal, this would mean removing anything panned toward the center of the mix and leaving only the portions that are far-flung toward the left or right sides. Suffice it to say that because of my amp’s compromised power stage, (through a phenomenon called phase cancellation), the left and right channels were being subtracted from each other instead of summed. Hence, A (left) minus B (right) as opposed to the usual A plus B we’re all used to hearing.
Since I recognized its sound and noted it in conversation, this clearly wasn’t the first time I’d ever heard that particular effect. Far from it. But it certainly was the first time I had thought about it in a long while. When I was a young house engineer in the ’90s, I was introduced to the technique of monitoring in A–B during mixdown for all kinds of useful purposes. For instance, you could zero in on phasing problems you might be noticing in the periphery, check if separate reverbs were playing nice together or combining poorly, verify desired separation between particular tracks, among other handy evaluations. I even read that the legendary mastering engineer Bob Ludwig was a frequent proponent of this listening technique and the insights it provided. Now, having had an accidental taste of it all these years later, I found myself craving this tool again.
And all because of an ancient, broken stereo that I, for unclear reasons, wanted so badly to buy and refurbish.
The steps to creating this subtractive image could not be simpler. It’s as easy as reversing the phase of one of your stereo channels and then summing them in mono. Either of the two channels will work, but general convention is to flip the right “B” channel (following the “A–B” nomenclature). My first thought was to build one of my usual party trick enclosures which I could patch between any source & load that I wished. However, what I really wanted was to hear A–B while mixing, and an external box was not going to accomplish that. I needed something that could flip the phase of B at a point after all my busses were funneled down to 2 signals, but before the console’s mono summing amplifier, and that meant I had to add something internally. (Yay!)
I’ll note that some mixing consoles already provide switching for A+B/A-B listening, but my M-520 is not one of those. As luck would have it though, this desk did come into my possession with a small modification that has never been of any use to me. The upshot was that it already had an extra hole drilled through the monitor section for a toggle switch of exactly the size I would need for my new function.
I’ll spare you the details of carving out the previous owner’s mod to the talkback mic switching. Let’s just say I deleted all that first. From there it was mostly a matter of finding a smart location for two 1:1 ratio “unity” isolation transformers. These small transformers, made specifically for audio, serve a couple of purposes. I originally bought them to eliminate some low-level noise I was sometimes hearing from my outboard effect returns during mixdown. As the name implies, isolation transformers are made for this very thing, and they would still serve that purpose beautifully. But now, secondly, the one for the right channel would also facilitate the phase inversion for my new function. A small DPDT toggle placed in the afore-mentioned hole was wired to optionally cross the output leads from that secondary coil, and voila! A–B available at the flick of a noiseless switch.
So again, beyond my general fetish for all things audio, I had no real idea why I had such a strong impulse to take on that old Grommes stereo at a time when I had so much work to do with endless ground to cover on other projects and on my professional development. Nevertheless, I gave in to the idea that, as long as I was following my fascination, the benefit would reveal itself eventually. Happily, I was right. I can’t believe it’s been so many years since I’ve had this trick in my bag.
To anyone taking the deep dive into a lifetime of continually improving your own mixes, I can’t recommend this simple technique enough. Especially if you’re at a stage where you’re concentrating on improved imaging. The ability to expose everything beyond the music’s natural focal point and foundation is wonderfully revealing and addictive. You’ll begin to think of it as the perfect tool in all kinds of instances, perhaps becoming as ingrained in you as the humble “solo” or “mute” button.
But some things are best when demonstrated. Some fun A–B examples of extremely well-known recordings are provided below. (I’m claiming “fair use” of these bastardized excerpts for educational purposes, so we’ll se how that goes.)